News

Making the Perfect Mince Pies for Christmas

Christmas pudding may have the name, but nothing quite screams Christmas like freshly baked mince pies. They are simple to make, and you can tinker around with the mincemeat to add some personal flair. While the perfect filling is a matter of taste, the case has to be light and crumbly. The technique and recipe below will ensure your mince pies are the envy of anyone lucky enough to get a sample!

Makes 18 individual pies (approx.)

INGREDIENTS

  • 8oz cold butter
  • 12oz plain flour
  • 3 1/2oz golden caster sugar
  • 10oz mincemeat
  • 1 small egg
  • Pinch of salt
  • Icing sugar, for dusting

EQUIPMENT

  • Bun tin - enough space for 18 pies
  • Glass or metal bowl
  • 2 table knives
  • Wire rack
  • Whisk or fork
  • Pastry brush

PERFECT MINCE PIE PASTRY

Let's begin with the technique for perfect shortcake-based pastry. You need to keep the butter as cool as possible throughout the process. If the butter gets too warm, your pastry may end up dense and flaky.

1. Sift the flour into a bowl.

2. Dice the chilled butter into small cubes and then add to the flour.

3. Use 2 table knives to cut the butter into the flour. Slice in opposing directions, almost scissor-fashion.

4. Once the pieces of butter become too small to slice, use your fingertips and thumbs to rub the butter into the flour. Use light pressure and lift the mixture up as you rub. This gets air into the mixture and ensures it remains cool.

5. If at anytime the mixture squishes or sticks to your fingers, cover the bowl and refrigerate for 10 minutes.

6. Continue until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs.

7. Add the castor sugar and a pinch of salt to the mixture and combine.

8. Gently bring the mix into a ball and knead a few times to trap more air into the pastry. If the mixture feels tacky, don't dust with flour, as this will ruin the final consistency. Instead, cover and refrigerate until firm.

MAKING THE CASES

If you are going to the effort of making mince pies, then don't hide it. Keep them rustic. There will be no rolling out or use of fancy pastry cutters here. It's all done by hand, literally.

9. Take a walnut-sized piece of your pastry and press it into one of the bun tin holes to form a case. The pastry will not expand, so the thickness you form will be the thickness once baked.

10. Spoon some mincemeat into the case.

11. Take a smaller piece of pastry and flatten it out in the palm of your hand to make a lid.

12. Place the lid on the base. Squeeze the edges together to seal.

13. You should get about 18 individual pies, depending on how thick you want your pies and how deep your filling.

14. You can freeze the pies now and cook later. They will keep for about a month. Or put them in the oven right away.

BAKING YOUR MINCE PIES

15. Preheat the oven to 390F/Gas Mark 6/350F for fan-assisted.

16. Beat the egg and brush some on the lid of each pie.

17. Place bun tins on middle shelf.

18. Cook for 20 mins, or until golden brown on top.

19. Remove from oven and leave to cool in the tin for 5 minutes.

20. Remove from tin and leave to cool on a wire rack.

21. Dust with the icing sugar before serving.

You can enjoy your mince pies now or place them in an airtight container and refrigerate. They will keep for 3-4 days.


Your choice of mouth-watering mincemeat filling now has the perfect pastry home. Whether sitting alone, saddled with brandy butter, cuddling next to ice-cream or covered in cream, your mince pies will be the Christmas treat everyone desires.

Frequently asked questions

What comes in a Baketivity baking kit?

Each Baketivity baking kit includes pre-measured dry ingredients, easy step-by-step instructions, and fun educational activities designed for kids. Our recipes are created to help children learn real kitchen skills while baking something delicious with their family.

Do I need to buy additional ingredients?

You may only need to add a few fresh ingredients like eggs, butter, or milk, depending on the recipe. Most of the dry ingredients come pre-measured in the kit, making baking simple, convenient, and mess-free for kids.

What equipment do I need to use the baking kits?

Most families already have everything they need at home. Typically you'll need mixing bowls, a whisk, fork or spoon, measuring cups, and a lined baking pan. Some recipes may also require a microwave-safe bowl or oven.

What age are Baketivity baking kits best for?

Baketivity baking kits are designed for kids ages 4–16. Younger children may need a little help from a parent, while older kids can follow the instructions more independently and build confidence in the kitchen.

Do your baking kits contain nuts?

Nuts are not directly included in the recipes or ingredient lists. However, some components may be produced in facilities that also process nuts, sesame seeds, soy, and gluten, so trace amounts may be present.

Are Baketivity baking kits kosher?

Yes! All ingredients included in Baketivity baking kits are OU-certified kosher, and our facility is FDA-approved, so families can bake and enjoy their treats with confidence.

My ingredients feel hard or clumpy. Is that normal?

Yes! Our ingredients are vacuum-packed to keep them fresh, which can sometimes make them feel firm or clumpy. Simply open the bag and give it a shake, and the ingredients will loosen up and be ready to use.

You might also like

Holiday Baking Traditions & Timeless Family Recipes

Holiday Baking Traditions & Timeless Family Recipes

Discover the heartwarming history behind holiday baking traditions. Learn how to keep family recipes alive, explore global festive treats, and create lasting memories in the kitchen this season.

View more
Holiday Cooking Challenges for Kids: Tips for Stress-Free Fun

Holiday Cooking Challenges for Kids: Tips for Stress-Free Fun

Cooking with kids during the holidays doesn't have to be stressful! Discover actionable tips to manage the mess, overcome kitchen challenges, and create joyful, fun-filled family memories.  

View more
20 Creative Homemade Christmas Gifts Kids Can Make

20 Creative Homemade Christmas Gifts Kids Can Make

Spread holiday cheer with 20 easy, budget-friendly homemade Christmas gifts kids can craft and bake themselves.

View more
Festive Holiday Cookie Exchange Ideas, Tips & Themes

Festive Holiday Cookie Exchange Ideas, Tips & Themes

Host the ultimate festive gathering this year! Discover creative recipes, planning tips, and fun themes to make your holiday cookie exchange a sweet and memorable success for everyone.  

View more
15 Irresistible No-Bake Christmas Desserts

15 Irresistible No-Bake Christmas Desserts

Skip the oven this year! Discover 15 quick, easy, and festive no-bake Christmas desserts that will save you time and keep the kitchen stress-free.

View more
Festive Drinks for Kids: Fun & Easy Holiday Recipes

Festive Drinks for Kids: Fun & Easy Holiday Recipes

Make the holidays magical for your little ones! Discover fun, colorful, and easy festive drinks for kids, from creamy hot cocoa to sparkling holiday mocktails.  

View more